One thousand, one hundred, and twenty-seven

May 31, 2013 — 27 Comments

55704f0cdb43cc0e300f6a706700e98f
PHOTO

When I started this blog, I started it for fun. I started it to talk about 90s nostalgia, pop culture, and thrift shopping. I didn’t start this blog to talk about sweat shops, fast fashion, and 1,127 dead people in a pile of rubble. Yet, here we are.

One thousand, one hundred, and twenty-seven.

That very long number is the number of people that perished in the Savar building collapse on April 24, 2013. You know the story by now: On April 23, a large crack was spotted in a Bangladesh Plaza that housed shops, offices, and a very large garment factory. Warnings to evacuate the building were heeded by some, but on the very next day, thousands of garment workers were ordered back to work and into the building. A few hours later, the building collapsed, and 1,127 people suffered a horrific death.

A crash that loud, and number that big, is hard to ignore. But with a crash that loud and a number that big, it’s hard to know what to say.

And yet, I feel a strange pressure to say something. I think that’s because nearly every article that attempts to offer some conscience-freeing solutions to this tragedy suggests more thrift shopping. By that measurement, people like me are star students. It’s easy, looking at my closet of 95% thrifted garments, to feel like a smug star student. Nearly every dollar I spent on clothing in the last two years has gone to the Salvation Army, BFM, or Talize. Looking at the images like this from Bangladesh, my inner monologue starts almost immediately: “Well, I didn’t buy any Joe Fresh last year. I don’t support slave labour. I can go back to reading TV recaps and stop feeling guilty.” But I don’t have a right to do that, because if I’m honest with myself, I didn’t start thrifting out of global concern. I started thrifting because I wanted to cool clothing for cheap prices. That right there is the very the same reason people go to Joe Fresh, F21 and Walmart. It’s the same game. That game has less harmful consequences when you play it in the thrift shop, but that mentality - more for less - is at the root of the fast fashion problem.

This problem needs addressing, and so, I’m going to address it. I’ll admit, I’ve sort of been waiting for someone else to say something, so I could just tweet a link to it and feel better. But sadly, the fashion blogging community has been nearly silent about this. Their silence comes from the fact that these cheaply-made garments are their bread and butter, and I’d imagine it’s hard to condemn the industry that fills up your side bar with ads. If it isn’t silence, then it’s a singular post stating that “my heart is with Bangladesh” and “I’ve donated what I spent on Joe Fresh to the relief fund”.

That last option is, of course, a good thing to do, but it’s not enough. What does it do to quell the production of the millions of garments still being produced by millions of people in other factories, in different countries? All the other retail giants (WalMart, Target, American Eagle) are still producing garments in buildings as packed, as inhumane, and maybe even as dangerous the one that fell down in Bangladesh. They just haven’t fallen down yet, so we haven’t heard the crash.  Outside the fashion blogging community, various bloggers and non-profits have attempted to provide some suggestions for consumers who are aghast at what the industry has come to. This article offers up some good ideas, and rightly points to thrift shopping as a good alternative (# 6), but again, I’m struck by the last two words in that sentence: “…save money!”

Donating money to the relief fund is good. Thrift shopping is good. Don’t stop doing these things, but they aren’t solutions if the bottom line is still about saving money. So what is the solution? What can we do to foster a more responsible garment industry?

Over the last couple of months, I’ve been in and out of Elizabeth’s Cline’s anti-fast-fashion manifesto, Overdressed. This book tells us all what we all already know, but are afraid to admit: We’re killing the earth, killing creativity, and killing people, by clothing ourselves the way we do. We don’t give a shit how our clothing is made, and we don’t give a shit who’s making it. It’s an excellent, sobering read, and while the book is full of enlightening facts and figures, I think the solution to the fast fashion problem is actually found in the first few chapters: We need to go back to spending more money on less clothing.

To address how we got so very overdressed in fast fashion, Cline starts with these stats: In 1950, the average middle-class salary was $4,237. The average person spent $437 of that amount on clothing. That’s more than 10% of one’s total income for the year going towards garments. That $437 probably resulted in, oh, 20 different outfits. If we kept up with that ratio today, someone with a salary $45,000 would spend around $4,500 on clothing. But you know what the average family spends on clothing every year? $1,700. And that family could get much more than 20 outfits with that amount.  If fact, if they wanted, that family could get a staggering 485 tee shirts from Forever 21 for that amount. Those cheap tees are courtesy of workers who spent most of their lives in buildings much like the one that collapsed in Bangladesh.

Those stats alone tell us that the way we dress ourselves now is not “just the way it is”, nor is it “how it’s always been.” Presently, we can’t imagine investing such a large sum into our wardrobes, forgetting that our grandparents and great-grandparents were doing just that. Many of them were poor, hard-working immigrants, and yet they were spending lots of money on better-made, ethically-produced clothing, and they still managed to build thriving lives for themselves and their families. When we tell ourselves that we can’t possibly find another cent in our current budget for clothing, we’re lying. We have the money to spend, we just don’t want to spend it. I just don’t want to spend it.

If you’ve been following this blog, you’ll know that I save a lot of money thrift shopping, and I brag about it. A lot. Where does that saved money go? It goes to phone data overages, food, beer, and the Apple Store. But what if I took that “saved money”, and put it back into the small minority of people who are attempting to manufacture clothing ethically? What if, when I felt the need to “splurge,” I splurged on items that are made in Canada? On items that are made by businesses that pay attention to human rights? On retailers that won’t wait for a building to collapse before they realize something is terribly wrong? That would be a solution.

I know, and you know, what we have do it, but man, it’s hard to do it.

Many people have a canned rebuttal for this kind of thinking. They’re quick to offer up something like this: “…But those sweat shops have saved economies! And employed millions of people! If you don’t shop there, you’re leaving them with nothing.” You know what I think that is? A load of bullshit. It’s not all or nothing. Would we ever propose that, since women prostituting themselves can’t find work outside of prostitution, we should support that industry, because they’ve gotta eat? Absolutely not. There is always a place to draw the line, and we should always strive to do better.

There is a third way. Yes, millions of people are employed in sweatshops, and they have jobs, but they deserve better jobs. They don’t just deserve jobs that pay them enough to eat, they deserve jobs that pay them enough to feed, house, and educate their families. Right now, they are “dependent on their own exploitation,” and that’s not good enough.

We’ve established that in order for there to be some change in all of this, we need to spend more money. Now here’s the crazy part: we wouldn’t even have to spend that much more. Cline says it best here:

Garment workers overseas are still only earning about 1 percent of the retail price of the clothing they pro­duce. The Worker Rights Consortium has found that garment worker wages could be doubled or even tripled with little or no increase for Ameri­can consumers. Clothing companies have enjoyed decades of cheap foreign labor and the resulting profits, but what exactly are the tangible benefits to us, the American [or Canadian] consumer? We own more clothes than we can wear, the quality and craftsmanship of our wardrobes is at an all-time low, and the U.S. manufacturing base can’t compete on wages with the developing world, costing our country countless jobs. One of the tools we have to change these dynamics is to not just demand that clothing companies stop using sweatshops, but to demand they pay those who make our clothes a living wage. It’s achievable, and the benefits would be far-reaching.

If we really believe that, we need to pass on that message to the powers that be with the medium that always speaks the loudest: our wallets.

This isn’t a pipe dream, and I’m too much of an idealist to think anything else. In a recent interview with NPR, Cline points to some of the transitions that have occurred in the food industry as beacons of hope, and I can attest to small examples of that in my own life. Just this morning, I walked past Williams Coffee Pub on my way into the office. I stopped for a coffee. I could’ve purchased the house blend, but instead I spent an additional $0.10 for the fair trade blend. Ethical coffee isn’t a novelty anymore, or something reserved for only the hippiest and dippiest coffee shops, it’s standard practice. Even in the coffee aisles at big-box grocery store, major brands like President’s Choice now offer fair trade alternatives. I can only assume that companies like President’s Choice started providing these options as a response to their consumers’ desires. It’s worth noting that President’s Choice is owned by Loblaw, the same parent company as Joe Fresh. So, we can surmise that Loblaw would provide ethical clothing alternatives, if they sensed a desire for it from their consumers. We need to show them that we desire the same thing for the fashion industry.

This is the part where I should leave you with an inspirational list of things to do, articles to read, and places to shop. The truth is, though, I haven’t gotten there yet. I’ve gotten nearly 1800 words down, and I’ve gotten a few things off my chest, but I’m still struggling with what to put back on. So, I’m going to do that thing bloggers do when they encounter their own limitations with the English language, and missappropriate the words of somebody far more eloquent.

Wise words from MLK // We So Thrifty

Thanks for reading, friends. Let’s all continuing struggling with this, ok?

27 responses to One thousand, one hundred, and twenty-seven

  1. 

    This article :http://www.refinery29.com/apparel-industry changed how I shop. I mostly thrift and eBay but I do like to fill in holes with online retail. I use the graded system in the article to point me in the right direction. I still have too much “bad” fashion in my closet but it’s getting less as I donate it or wear it out!

  2. 
    Erika Edmondstone May 31, 2013 at 9:35 pm

    Dame Westwood has been saying this for a while now – buy less, spend more. Or in other words, go for ethical quality over cheap quantity. It applies equally to our food, if it comes from depleted, chemical laden soils it’s probably cheaper in the short term ,but it costs the planet a hell of a lot more and it’s nowhere near as good for you, immediately or in the long term as produce from an organic or bio-dynamic farm. Which tastes so much better too!

    Great post, thank you for writing it. I hope it makes more people think about their shopping and consumption patterns.

  3. 

    Interesting points. I never realized that people spent so much of their income on clothes in past. I’ll have to add Overdressed to my summer reading list.

  4. 

    Wow Julie, so well written. Thank you for taking the time to write this down and to research what you did. I have heard lots of this before and I do a fair amount of thrift shopping both for price and ethical reasons, but I’m feeling a new conviction level tonight.

  5. 

    I like your article, Julie. I enjoy all your articles, but this is a subject that has consumed me too. My closet is bare like Mother Hubbard’s cupboard (spelling? been too long since I read the rhyme) I have been putting off getting any new clothes because I have oh-so-precious little money and just want a few cheap plain t-shirts but haven’t wanted to go to Walmart for those cheap deals since the tragedy.

    I have been reading about life in India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh for quite a few years now and know it very well. I was excited to read about the backlash from the Bangladeshis in the country because no one can change a country from without, it must happen from within and without simultaneously, but primarily from within. What people endure in those countries without even bad jobs is almost inconceivable to us and so to act here in ways that drastically affect the clothing industry out of self-righteousness without understanding those countries in depth is irresponsible. If we can find out which companies act responsibly and choose their goods over others we certainly can apply proper pressure. Supply and demand. That’s how it works.

    I have been thinking for quite a while now that if I shopped like you, thrift shopping, little by little, I’d have a HELL of a wardrobe by now! LOL As an artist I can have a lot of fun expressing myself with many different fashions. And yet…basic black is what you can expect to see me wearing most days. All the creativity ends up in my art. It’s time to start having fun again though.

  6. 

    Thank you! I think this message is so important. Etsy is an excellent way to shop with this goal in mind. For example, I bought a diaper bag from Malaysia and it is amazingly functional and well made and handsome… and ONE person made it! One person who was able to enjoy her work — was satisfied by the result of it, and compensated fairly for it. How amazing is that?! I get super excited about Etsy (just ask my husband!).

  7. 

    Thank you so much for addressing the Bangladesh story. I, too, am concerned by how few fashion bloggers are willing to talk about what happened. I agree with your thoughts about the need to spend thoughtfully. My new clothing goal now: work with what I have and think very carefully before purchasing something new.

  8. 

    Hey Julie…here’s an article relevant article: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/16/business/global/after-bangladesh-seeking-new-sources.html?pagewanted=all

    If it doesn’t display as an active link try cutting and pasting. It is definitely worth looking at. About the Bangladeshi incident, fallout, and clothier reactions regarding seeking new markets!

  9. 

    Truly brilliantly put! And you’re right! The blogging community had been deafeningly silent on this. But I haven’t read anything better put than this! Thanks!!

  10. 

    Thank you for posting about the tragedy in Bangladesh. I remember when I heard about the collapse, I was shocked about the number of workers and the ignorance of safety by people in charge.

    And you’re right– like many people I also thought, Good thing I didn’t shop at [insert store here] this year. But not visiting a certain retailer doesn’t make me or anyone less guilty. Accidents can happen at factories any where in the world at any time regardless of the brand’s size or popularity. Real change can start with us– the consumers– because we often buy what we like, want, don’t really want, need, or really need without thinking too much about who made our product and his/her living and working conditions.

    Like you, I thrift, too or buy secondhand clothing from eBay or local stores. But I also shop at the mall. We can’t stop shopping altogether, but I hope your post encourages others to be more aware. It has certainly become a reminder for me.

  11. 

    Great article Julie. I can not understand all the content, despite my bad English, but the background of the reflection is perfect and matches my thinking. I also think that the fashion blogging community should respond to these situations, but many times we were only on the surface … The people of the Western world must think of where our wealth comes from where come the goods we buy and who are struggling to produce them. The capitalist system has these contradictions and these problems, and it is important to be aware of it. A great reflection, Julie.
    I love your style, your looks. Now, well, I love you as a person. Thank you for this post.

  12. 

    Thank you for writing this. I didn’t realize how quiet bloggers have been about this issue until you pointed it out, but it’s true. I struggle with enjoying fashion but feeling like I need to have a more conscious closet for both environmental and humanitarian reasons. Thank you for inspiring and motivating me in that endeavour. I would love to read more from you (and other bloggers as well) about this topic.

  13. 

    My hubby and I have been having this conversation for years. People accuse us of being “cheap” because we buy second-hand stuff and try not to have excessive items in our home. I hate the injustice in that but hope that each time something like this tragedy happens more people will see the need to make drastic changes to their life choices. Thanks so much for writing and sharing your thoughts.

  14. 

    Great points all around, and very inspiring! Thank you for the thoughtful discussion of this important issue.

  15. 

    Great article.
    I have been trying to socially conscious about my shopping habits but it is hard to do. Just quickly: avoiding all overseas produced products and shopping “Made in Canada /USA” is not always the answer. Some overseas factories do produce goods in keeping with International Labor Organization (ILO) standards while there have been sweatshops busted in Toronto, Montreal and Calgary in recent years. Some companies subcontract to workers paid by the piece for basic sewing and assembly and they get much less than minimum wage.
    I am trying to learn which companies to support and continuing to shop the second-hand market as well. It is worth noting however, that not all sellers on ebay or etsy, are ethical retailers, though the number of problematic ones is likely reduced compared to the norm.
    There are organizations to look to for info like Maquila Solidarity Network, Oxfam and others for more info.

  16. 

    I’m really glad to see this posting. I’ve seen one other posting on my blogroll, and I wrote a reflection about it as well (which was nowhere near as thoughtful as this one), but that’s been it. This has really shaken me up, and I’m concerned that the lack of caring overall just continues to reflect our consumer culture mentality. As my pastor says, “I don’t want to be a consumer; I want to be a producer.” I’m going to take some time in the next couple of weeks and start a list of links connected with ethical shopping because I feel like people need alternatives. Yes, I shop secondhand, but there are some things (undies! socks! workout clothes!) that I would ALWAYS like to buy new, and it’s going to be more difficult to find these products from places I feel good about it instead of just popping into Target and aimlessly shopping. Thank you for taking the time to write this, and I look forward to seeing future discussions about this topic.

  17. 

    Reblogged this on Nav in the City and commented:
    Thank you Julie for bringing attention to this issue that we all need to be more aware of. I hope this makes us all think twice about where our merchandise is really coming from and what it truly costs.

  18. 

    Reblogged this on Pauperintoprincess and commented:
    Of course I heard about the terrible tragedies in Bangladesh from the clothing factory collapse, but I didn’t notice how quiet the blogger community had been about it until I read this post but it’s so true.

    I mainly shop second hand to save money and entertain/express myself but can’t help but be proud of also being more sustainable and ethical. It seems totally win-win to me. I’m skeptical about fair trade as there’s no official definition of a “fair price” (http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/2668/are-fair-trade-products-guaranteed-to-be-fairer), but I certainly think a bit of lobbying of large brands wouldn’t go amiss.

    I think I’ll run a ‘Splurge Friday’ piece on splurging on ethical fashion (starting with Etsy!) – thoughts?

    xxx

  19. 

    Your article was so thought provoking. Thanks for putting this out there. I featured your blog and specifically the link to this article on my little blog today.

  20. 

    Thank you, Julie, for writing this post. Thank you.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. Forward « We So Thrifty - June 8, 2013

    […] I hit “publish” on last Friday’s article, it has easily become the most-viewed post I’ve written this year. That is amazing, because […]

  2. Weekly Reader: June 3 – June 9 2013 | My Whatever Book - June 9, 2013

    […] has been unnaturally silent regarding the Savar building collapse in Bangladesh. Consequently, We So Thrifty, a thrift-shop-only fashion blogger, recently took a stand and asked that as consumers in the […]

  3. Polka dots and perfect tees « We So Thrifty - June 20, 2013

    […] ya’ll know, I spilled a whole bunch of words on the Bangladesh factory a few weeks ago. I discussed some of my thoughts on the fast-fashion, and […]

  4. An update to humanitarian fashion | Thrift Eye - June 30, 2013

    […] to do a big follow up to my post on thinking about fashion in a humanitarian and responsible way. Julie’s post at We So Thrifty put it into a bigger perspective, I highly recommend you read it. She makes a fantastic point that […]

  5. WHY I THRIFT | Second Hand Stories - July 27, 2013

    […] reading the post about the Bangladesh sweatshops by We So Thrifty, I see yet another ethical benefit of this lifestyle, beyond “Oh, I just like […]

  6. THRIFT TIPS // SHOES | Emily Leclerc - August 7, 2013

    […] CANADIAN? (Represent!!) Check out Julie’s blog We so Thrifty – and make sure to read this post while you are […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s